Search This Blog

Saturday, July 1, 2017

The Hopewellian Connection

        One of my philosophies is that everyone should explore their own community and learn the rich history it contains. Recently I discovered that I was a good example of someone who thought they knew the history of their community pretty well but really only knew part of the story….
My story begins with a visit to a newly restored 1912 post office that was being presented by my local historical society.[1] While there, I struck up a conversation with a few of volunteers and in no time the discussion turned to local history and Indian mounds. Being well read on the subject, I was asked if I knew much about the mound that was located on a nearby island. Of course I knew of the mound but explained that I didn’t think that there was a whole lot to tell. We exchanged a few more stories about local history and after complimenting them on the beautifully restored post office, I proceeded to get on with my day. 
       Later that same week I was contacted by a representative of the Indian Lake Historical Society and asked if I would be interesting in undertaking an exploratory inquiry into the local Indian Mound. Knowing that the mound has never been fully excavated and convinced that little is known about the mound, I thought  it would only take a few calls and minor research to acquire all the known information. I said yes…. and so began my discovery of a history that has nearly been forgotten by everyone.
        The subject of my inquiry was a mound known as the Dunn’s Pond mound. It is located  on the south eastern shore of Indian Lake Ohio. It is nearly twelve feet tall at its highest point and has a diameter of approximately eighty feet. The mound itself was built around 2500 years ago during the time of the Hopewell culture. It is very likely a burial mound.[2]

        At one time the mound was part of 15 mound group that stood alongside a marsh littered with islands, ponds and streams all connecting to the Great Miami River.[3] However, after the signing of the Lewistown Treaty and the creation of Indian Lake the fate of fourteen of the fifteen mounds along with much of the original landscape was sealed.[4]
        Modern researchers don’t know exactly what happened to 14 of the 15 mounds. Most researchers believe that the mounds met their fate during the expansion and colonization of the Lewistown (Indian Lake) region. The mounds are most likely under the lake or plowed into oblivion in favor of farming interests and urban sprawl.
        Ironically the people who built the mounds are in some ways responsible for their own demise… How can a 3000 year old culture be responsible for the actions of people whom they never came in contact with?..............I will explain the connection a little later in the post… but first let’s get back to the mound.
        Since it is very likely to find a Hopewell burial mound within close proximity to a village and it is also likely to find villages within close proximity to waterways, it is of no surprise that the Dunn’s Pond Mound overlooks, what was originally; a collection of streams and creeks that fed a marsh leading to the Miami River. 3000 years ago this area would have been prime real estate for a group of horticulturalists like the Hopewell Indians.[5] With a group of 15 mounds within a close proximity of one another it is highly likely that there was a significant population of ancient Native Americans living within the area that is now called Indian Lake. However, don’t picture a bunch of Indians trying to stay warm and dry while living in a tee pee, that is not how the Hopewell lived.
The Hopewell lived in small communities of 2 to 12 families called hamlets and they lived in thatch wattle houses

        Each village or hamlet was associated with a mound or a series of mounds. So, the fact that there were 15 mounds all located within a few yards of each other tells us that there must have been a significant population to support all of those mounds.[6] However, little evidence remains of their existence. Even though there were ruins of villages documented in the late 1800’s there are no signs of them today. Most likely the villages met the same fate as the majority of the mounds, and were demolished in favor of European expansion. The sad fact is that there is little to no surviving artifacts of the Hopewell anywhere at Indian Lake. There are no surviving village ruins, no grand ceremonial earthworks, and since we are talking about pre historic times, there is no written history to pass on. The lone testament to the people who called this place home long before the white man arrived is the Dunn’s Pond mound and it stands largely unexplored and nearly forgotten.
        Why should we care about a mound that was built by people who were not of European or African heritage and died out hundreds of years before we even arrived on this continent?
        Like it or not those of us living in the good ‘ol USA owe a debt of gratitude to the Hopewell. They were the first culture in the Americas to not only explore the art of long term farming but to invent many of the methods that were passed on from generation to generation.
        When the white man first settled in the new world it was the natives who taught them how to plant maze, beans and squash, the very same foods harvested by the Hopewell. It is very well documented that the first successful settlements in America could not have survived without the help of the Native Americans and the Native Americans are decedents of the Hopewell people. …….So if it were not for the Hopewell’s dedication to farming the natives who helped the settlers may not have had the knowledge to share with the Europeans and if not for the shared knowledge about farming, the Europeans would not have survived in the New World.[7]  However, because of the Hopewell; there was a knowledge about farming that could be passed on to the Europeans and because of that knowledge, European settlements found success. Once the Europeans found success they began to expand and we all know what happened when the Europeans decided to expand across the continent. Needless to say it didn’t far very well for the Natives inhabitants let alone the ancient ruins that had very little meaning to those who felt that the native culture was inferior to their own.
        With that in mind it is not a surprise that the Dunn’s Pond Mound is one of the few surviving things that still remains of an ancient culture that once dominated the Indian Lake region. It is also no surprise that most people couldn’t care less about the giant dirt hill and it is of little surprise that the mound sits unkempt, overgrown and forgotten by most. However, what I discovered during my inquiry on the mound was that this mound was not simple a forgotten eyesore of a culture that has little to do with the one that exists today. Instead I discovered that if it were not for the Hopewell; me, you, and practically every other person living in North America may not have had the chance to grow up in what once called the New World. The New World would not have been colonized if it were not for the lessons in farming passed on by the Native Americans and so the next time you see you hear about an Indian Mound and you ask yourself why bother, remember the horticulturalists of the Hopewell culture. 
        Like it or not those mounds of dirt are not simply ruins of a conquered people, those mounds are part of the story of us and part of the American culture.





[1] Abbi Adelsbergerl, and Cole McDaniel, "Open house set for historic post office at Indian Lake," Peak of Ohio, July 6, 2016,  http://peakofohio.com/news/details.cfm?id=218106#.WVWJJulGm70.

[2] Sean R. Heights, An Inquiry into the Indian Lake Mounds, Inquiry and Field Study May11 - June 18, 2017, Indian Lake Historical Society, Russells Point, Ohio: Heights on History, 2017.

[3] William C. Mills, 1860-1928,"Archaeological Atlas of Ohio,” Logan County, page 46, Ohio Digital Resource Commons. 1914, https://drc.ohiolink.edu/handle/2374.OX/169348.

[4] Charles J. Kappler, ed. "Vol. II, Treaties: Treaty With the Seneca, Etc., 1831," Indian Affairs: Laws and Treaties, pgs, 327-33,. Government Printing Office, 1904,  http://digital.library.okstate.edu/kappler/Vol2/treaties/sen0327.htm.

[5] Susan L.Woodward, and Jerry N. McDonald, Indian Mounds of the Middle Ohio Valley: A Guide to Adena and Ohio Hopewell Sites, McDonald and Woodward Publishing Company, 1986.

[6] Bradley Thomas Lepper, Ohio Archaeology: An Illustrated Chronicle of Ohio's Ancient American Indian Culture, Wilmington, Ohio: Orange Frazer Press, 2005, pg78 – 170.

[7] Dave Zuchowski, "Native Americans played-crucial role in settlers survival," Pittsburgh Post Gazette, Nov. 24, 2010, http://www.post-gazette.com/local/south/2010/11/24/Native-Americans-played-crucial-role-in-settlers-survival/stories/201011240253.

Photography and Art


(Hopewell Hamlet) : http://archive.archaeology.org/online/features/hopewell/who_were_hopewell.html




Restoration Has Begun


A lot has happened since the rediscovery of the Dunn’s Pond Mound. The short little inquiry I performed led to a presentation that set attendance records at the historical society. Even though very few people were aware of its existence prior to the presentation, the Mound sparked a flood of interest and action. It seems that once people knew about the mound the more people felt connected to it and the more they wanted to save it for future generations.... So.... back to the mound I went.
My inquiry turned into a full blown historical survey of the sight that was presented to the Ohio Department of Natural Resources and the Ohio Parks Department for review. Within a few weeks the Parks Department agreed to turn the restoration and preservation responsibilities over to the Indian Lake Area Historical Society. With that a few legal documents were signed and the Dunn's Pond Mound became the Historical Societies responsibility.

Wanting to do things correctly modern day horticulturalists as well as mound preservationists were consulted. After all the opinions were heard and a strategy was determined, the process of restoration was set into motion. 
The entire restoration and public presentation process will take months if not years to complete but at least the process has begun. We are one step closer to guaranteeing that this 2000 year old representation of the past will be around for future generations to study and enjoy. Goes to show how much can be accomplished when you explore the history of your own community and get involved.
For the time being the ancient burial sight known as the Dunn's Pond Mound is safe from modern expansion and once again it can rise up out of the Ohio wilderness and stare down at the waters of the Great Miami River and once again become a spiritual place of contemplation and wander.
Dunn's Pond Mound before restoration

Dunn's Pond Mound after the first stage of restoration
September 2017

Friday, March 10, 2017

The Miamisburg Mound

        For my first historical entry I am going to tell you about one of my favorite ancient Native American sites, the Miamisburg Mound. For most of you this pile of dirt, wood and stone is not exactly at the top of your must see list however, after you finish reading this post it very well may be.
        Located in Southern Ohio within the region known as the Miami Valley there is a small town of about 20,000 residents known as Miamisburg. Beautiful and inviting as the small town atmosphere may be the one thing that separates this town from a thousand others, is its connection with an ancient culture that has long disappeared. Located near the edge of the city and nestled just out of view from a major freeway is the awe -inspiring Miamisburg Mound. The reason I say that the mound is awe-inspiring is because this mound is no ordinary hill in the yard. This mound is 68 feet tall with a diameter of about 300 feet. For those of us who like some kind of visual, the Miamisburg Mound is 2 feet taller than the Great Sphinx of Giza and the Mound’s base is roughly 60 feet longer than the one that supports the Sphinx. In other words, this thing is HUGE.[1]

                                                      Figure 1 Miamisburg Mound photo taken by Sean Heights
        The purpose and origin of the Miamisburg Mound has never been universally agreed upon and for the most part, the mound is often overlooked and forgotten by those who want to explore the early cultures of the Americas. The mound is so overlooked that it goes virtually unmentioned on the city’s own website.[2] When viewing the signage posted by the mound, one can easily see another example of just how forgotten this site has become. The signage put in place by the Ohio Historical Society provides a brief history of the mound and explains that the mound and the site in general have never been fully excavated. In fact the most recent attempted exploration of the mound occurred in the late 1800’s. Upon my first visit to the mound, that fact took me by surprise. After all the Miamisburg Mound is one of the largest conical mounds in North America. One would think that alone would garner some interest from the archaeological community. The fact that the mound has never been fully excavated becomes even stranger considering the conflicting opinions surrounding the mounds purpose.
                                   Figure 2: The signage provided by the Ohio Historical Society.
        Officially it is believed that the mound was constructed sometime between 1000 B.C.  and 400 A.D., during which it served as a burial site and a primitive man-made communication tower. One of the reasons this is the accepted theory is because the geographic location of the mound falls within a chain of high vantage points that were discovered to have been used as ancient signaling posts during the time of the Adena culture. The Miamisburg Mound as well as the other natural vantage points were found to have had several layers of ash that had accumulated on or near the highest point of each of the structures. The official explanation for geological oddity of an ash layer is that the vantage points, including Miamisburg Mound; were used by the native peoples to communicate with one another over great distances via fire and / or smoke signal.[3] The belief is that Miamisburg Mound was constructed because of a lack of high vantage points within the area. This explanation does help to explain why there has never been any great need to thoroughly explore the mound and it also helps to explain why the mound was built so high.
        If that was all the evidence that the research could provide than the communication tower explanation would be perfectly fine but like any good mystery, the official explanation is not the only published explanation.
        Another explanation is that the mound may have been used as a communication tower by later generations but the original purpose of the mound was more in line with the mounds found scattered all over Ohio and Indiana. This explanation argues that the mound was built to house the dead.
What is so unusual about this assertion you ask?......Read on and you will see……
        In the late 1950’s the United States government funded an inquiry into the origins of the mound. What was discovered by that inquiry was that the written accounts of the three partial excavations that were done in the 1800’s revealed some disturbing if not controversial findings. The inquiry found that the older records indicated that the mound and the surrounding area may be the final resting place of giants…….Holy History Channel!.........did he just say giants?..... Yes, you read that right. The inquiry found reports that some of the bones and artifacts recovered in and around the mound were proportionally equivalent to a race of humans who were somewhere around 8 feet tall. Reportedly the artifacts were so unbelievable that the then Governor and future President Rutherford B. Hayes traveled the nearly 80 miles from the capital just to see them. Along with the unusually large artifacts, the inquiry also revealed that earlier researchers believed there to be a large void or hollow structure near the base of the mound. Inquiry researchers believed the void to be most likely the remnants of a burial chamber. However, this burial chamber would be much larger in size than any that had currently been discovered.[4] The entire inquiry was summed up with this conclusion. "The vicinity abounds with evidence of the existence of a mammoth race, skilled in the art of war 
and much farther advanced in civilization than any other Indian tribe of which we have authentic knowledge."[5]
So why did the story of the communication tower become the accepted theory?
        The answer is simple. Even though there are newspaper clippings and official inquiries describing alternate theories about the mound, there is no supporting physical evidence. There are only reports of very large bones, tools and weapons being unearthed. There are no known surviving artifacts and there are no known photographs of the giant bones or any other unusual artifact. All there really is, is this interesting little story and the mystery of why no-one has bothered to fully excavate the Miamisburg Mound, if for no other reason than to erase all doubt about what is inside that magnificent mound of earth and wood.




[1] The Great Sphinx of Giza is 66 ft tall, 63 ft wide and 238 ft long. Dirk Laukens, The Great Sphinx of Giza, November 2015, http://www.ancient-egypt-online.com/the-great-sphinx.html.

[2] There is no specific mention of the mound and it can only be found through a search of the website. The City of Miamisburg, http://www.ci.miamisburg.oh.us/.

[3] For more on the mound being used for communication see Howard Burba, "The Day They Opened the Miamisburg Mound," Dayton Daily News, February 28, 1932: http://www.daytonhistorybooks.com/miamisburgmound.html.

[4] To view the official inquiry see Lorraine M. Russell, 1960, “Brief Historical Background of Miamisburg Indian Mound”, United States, doi:10.2172/934603, http://www.osti.gov/scitech/servlets/purl/934603.
[5] Ibid., pg. 7.